Hello dear
Welcome to Duetto Pizza and Gelato
Duetto Pizza and Gelato is a delightful culinary gem nestled in Key West, Florida. Located at 540 Greene St, this hidden treasure shines with its fresh, handmade pizzas and delectable gelato, crafted daily on-site. Customers rave about the vibrant atmosphere and the exceptional service provided by the friendly staff. The homemade crust and generous toppings elevate their pizzas to a must-try status, often touted as some of the best in America. Whether indulging in a slice or savoring a scoop of gelato, every visit promises a satisfying experience that will keep you coming back for more.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Caesar Salad
Banana-Strawberry
Rostini
Torino
About
Duetto Pizza and Gelato
Welcome to Duetto Pizza and Gelato, a true culinary gem nestled in the heart of Key West, Florida. Located at 540 Greene St #1, this delightful establishment invites you to savor the comfort of expertly crafted pizza and the refreshing indulgence of freshly made gelato. With a reputation that seems to outshine many eateries in the area, Duetto is more than just a place to eat—it's a delectable experience that keeps both locals and visitors coming back.
What makes Duetto stand out? The glowing reviews tell the story. Customers rave about the handmade pizza which utilizes a homemade crust skillfully tossed and generously topped. One delighted patron, Martin Fritsch, praised the pizza as "way better than average" and even noted its ranking as one of the best in America on TripAdvisor. This kind of acclaim doesn't come easy but speaks volumes about the quality found here.
But pizza isn’t the only star of the show. If you’re in the mood for something sweet, the freshly made gelato is not to be missed. Amanda Veinott’s daughters absolutely loved their gelato, produced daily on-site—a testament to Duetto's commitment to freshness and flavor. Each scoop reflects a passion for crafting authentic Italian desserts, and it’s clear that this establishment cares deeply about its offerings.
Customer experiences at Duetto are consistently elevated by the friendly staff, who ensure that every visit is special. Whether it's the tall gentleman with curly hair, who stood out for his welcoming service, or the efficient team dedicated to quick service, you will feel right at home. As Thomas Howe suggests, it’s wise to call ahead for collection to enjoy your meal at its freshest.
In conclusion, Duetto Pizza and Gelato promises a cozy atmosphere where you can take a break from your Key West adventures. With delicious, handmade pizza, freshly-scooped gelato, and a staff that treats you like family, it’s no wonder why this spot is often described as a must-visit destination. Dive into a slice or two, savor the rich flavors of their gelato, and soak in the vibrant spirit of Key West right here at Duetto.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Wow! What a hidden gem in Key West. We didn't try the pizza because we weren't that hungry but our girls LOVED the gelato. They make it every day at the store, fresh. The staff was phenomenal - the tall gentleman with curly hair was so friendly. 10/10 highly recommend. ”
“ We were hungry after a boat trip and looking for a quick snack, and wow, this was a good decision. Great handmade pizza for a fair price, way better than average. It even seems to be one of the best places to eat pizza in America (based on a Tripadvisor ranking). That's impressive, so go for it! ”
“ Extremely good pizza. In and out spot to grab a slice (or several) ”
“ Easily the best pizza in Key West. Are here 7 years ago and knew we had to return. Pizza was absolutely delicious and service very quick. Staff are very friendly and there is space to wait for it to be cooked. Recommend calling ahead for Collection. ”
“ Spectacular pizza. We were on a boat all day and wanted pizza. Walked over and ordered a pie. Took about 15 minutes. It was great. Homemade crust. Watched the guy hand toss it and load on all the toppings. It tasted as good as it looked. They did offer slices to go. Had drinks and Gelato. Not a lot of places to sit. The staff was very friendly and gave us Plates and silverware. They had freshly created Parmagan. Overall a great place for pizza. ”
“ Incredible pizza and antipasto salad. Loved every second of it. So much so I ended up getting a little sloppy. No one was looking though. I was hidden in a dark corner outside, no one saw me eating salad with my fingertips. It was magic. ”
“ These photos don't do the pizza justice because the slices are pretty big, but definitely a spot to try out if you're craving pizza. Not surprised how busy this spot was on a Friday night around 8/9pm with takeouts, dine-ins, and their own delivery service. Ordered three slices (17), pictured here: Pepperoni, Italia (also the solo photo), and Oofah. You can smell and taste the garlic on both the Italia and Oofah. Maybe will order well done next time as the slices were slightly floppy, but still delicious. Would come back also to try their gelato. ”
“ Duetto is hands-down one of the best pizza spots in Key West! They have a great variety of slices—huge, delicious, and full of flavor. I tried a couple and loved them all. The service was top-notch—super friendly and quick. Now the gelato... OMG! Their Key Lime gelato is easily the best I’ve had in the Keys—don’t skip it! Only small complaint: the cheesy garlic bread felt more like a pizza than actual garlic bread—maybe something for the owners to tweak. Still, this place is a gem! ”